Then the king will say to those at his right hand, “Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world, for I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was naked and you gave me clothing, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.” Then the righteous will answer him, “Lord, when was it that we saw you hungry and gave you food or thirsty and gave you something to drink? And when was it that we saw you a stranger and welcomed you or naked and gave you clothing? And when was it that we saw you sick or in prison and visited you?” And the king will answer them, “Truly I tell you, just as you did it to one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did it to me.”
—Matthew 25:34–40
When I was in high school, the city-wide youth group I was part of took to making friendship bracelets with the letters WWJD on them.
Do you remember those bracelets?
I often had two or three on my wrist, a permanent fixture even after they got kind of grey and grubby. The letters stood for “What Would Jesus Do?” They were supposed to remind us teenagers that our actions needed to be guided by Jesus.
Honestly, I think that thought was completely lost on most of us.
For me, the question prompted a somewhat sanctimonious adherence to rules, rather than any serious wrestling with what it meant to follow Jesus in the world. It also became a bit of a weird talisman.
I would look at my wrist before a math test and send up a quick prayer that Jesus would somehow magically intervene on my lack of studying.
Yup. Total irony.
We thought we had wittily created the phrase, too. None of us realized that the book which helped popularize it, In His Steps: What Would Jesus Do?, was written by the Rev. Charles Sheldon in 1896.
I read it in Divinity School, and it became clear that Teenaged Lynne had missed the point.
Unfortunately, I’m not entirely sure I’m that much further ahead some 45 years later.
It seems so hard to distill our decision-making into one catchy phrase. The older I get, the less life looks black and white and the more it looks like a whole bunch of shades of grey.
I try to make thoughtful choices. I try to step back and consider what faith asks of me. But I also know how often I react out of fear, grief, or selfishness before I’ve done any of that.
Sometimes I would prefer Jesus to offer me a tidy flowchart. Preferably one with an arrow that says, “Lynne, go this way.”
Instead, Jesus tells stories. He asks questions. He meets people. He pays attention to the ones everybody else has learned to overlook.
And in Matthew 25, he tells us where we might find him.
Hungry. Thirsty. A stranger. Without clothing. Sick. In prison.
Well.
That’s a bit more complicated than wearing a bracelet, isn’t it?
The people in this passage are surprised. They ask Jesus when they saw him hungry or thirsty or in need. They hadn’t recognized him in the people they met. They had simply responded to someone who needed food, welcome, care, or company.
As Elisabeth Johnson notes in her Working Preacher commentary on Matthew 25, the kingdom in this story is described as an inheritance: a gift, not a prize earned by keeping track of good deeds. The people Jesus calls righteous weren’t calculating how to secure God’s favour. They were caring for their neighbours.
That matters to me, because I can turn almost anything into a test. Even compassion.
Did I do enough? Did I do it properly? Did I get the answer right?
But perhaps the question isn’t whether I can make myself impressive enough for Jesus. Perhaps it’s whether I’m willing to notice the person in front of me—and respond with the love I have already received.
That doesn’t mean the choices are always simple. We can disagree about the best way to help. We need to listen rather than assume we know what another person needs. We need to care about the conditions that leave people hungry, isolated, or without a safe place to live, as well as the immediate needs right in front of us.
And we need to remember that the people Jesus names are not projects. They are our neighbours, with dignity, agency, stories, and gifts of their own. Sometimes we are the ones offering care. Sometimes we are the ones who need it.
There is something else here that has been sitting with me.
Over the past few weeks, I’ve had many conversations with people who are deeply sad and disappointed by the loss of their faith communities. People who have poured decades of their lives into churches they love, only to see those communities wither around them.
It IS sad. It IS disappointing.
These aren’t just buildings or numbers on a page. They are places where people were baptized, married, buried, and held through some of the most difficult moments of their lives. They are friendships, familiar hymns, shared meals, and generations of prayers.
When a church closes or changes beyond recognition, there is real grief. We need room to lament it. We need to tell the stories, shed the tears, and honour what has been.
Following Jesus doesn’t mean pretending that none of it hurts.
But grief can sometimes make us look backward so steadily that we stop noticing what is in front of us. We can become so occupied with wondering how to get the church back to the way it used to be that we miss the people Christ is asking us to love now.
I understand the longing. I really do. We remember full pews and busy programs, and we wonder what went wrong. We wonder whether we can somehow find the right plan, the right minister, or the right program to bring it all back.
Yet I don’t hear Jesus saying, “I was hungry and you restored your former prominence.”
He says, “I was hungry and you gave me food.”
He doesn’t ask whether the person we welcome will join the church or help us keep the lights on. He asks us to welcome them.
That is a challenging distinction. Because people can tell when they are being welcomed as beloved neighbours and when they are being recruited to solve somebody else’s problem.
Our calling is bigger than our fear for the institution. And it is more immediate than a plan to recreate the past.
What would happen if, alongside all our necessary conversations about buildings and budgets and the future, we asked: Who is hungry in our community? Who is lonely? Who is sick? Who has been treated like a stranger? Who is already doing the work of care, and how might we join them?
We may not be able to do everything. Some of us are tired. Some are grieving. Some need care ourselves. Following Jesus is not an invitation to run ourselves into the ground or pretend we have resources we don’t.
It is an invitation to take the next faithful step together.
Perhaps that step is a meal. A visit. A phone call. A conversation with someone whose experience we haven’t understood. Perhaps it is sharing what we have, speaking up for a neighbour, or making space for someone else to lead.
Small things, maybe.
But Jesus seems to think they matter.
So, my friends, let’s be gentle with one another as we grieve the churches and communities we have loved. Let’s give thanks for the faithfulness that brought us here, without asking the past to tell us everything the future must be.
And then, with God’s help, let’s turn our feet toward Jesus again.
Not toward a hope of regaining our past prominence, but toward a renewed commitment to his way: feeding, welcoming, visiting, listening, sharing, and loving our neighbours.
We don’t have to know exactly what the church will look like in the years ahead to begin.
We can follow Jesus here. We can follow him now.
Together.
Blessings today, my friends, and remember: you are Loved.
~Rev. Lynne